Tesla WeBuyAnyCar valuation

The Brutal Truth: What Your Tesla is Really Worth at WeBuyAnyCar UK - 53

Thinking about selling your EV? A UK car fan digs into the brutal truth of your Tesla WeBuyAnyCar valuation, why depreciation is so high, and how to fight back.

Sherif Butt

Sherif Butt

— 6 min read
A Tesla owner looking shocked at the low valuation offer for his vehicle at a WeBuyAnyCar branch.
The moment of truth for many Tesla owners—facing the reality of rapid EV depreciation at a car-buying service.

Right, let's have a proper chat about this. A mate of mine, absolutely buzzing, bought a shiny new Tesla Model Y last year. Paid a fortune for it, as you do. Last week, he popped down to his local WeBuyAnyCar just to see what it was worth. He came back looking like he’d seen a ghost. The offer was so low it was almost comical. Gobsmacked doesn't even cover it.

And he's not alone. The internet is full of these stories—people discovering their high-tech pride and joy has shed value faster than a dog sheds hair in summer. So what's really going on with the Tesla WeBuyAnyCar valuation? Is it a complete rip-off, or is there something bigger at play? Let's dig in.

Table of Contents

  1. The Brutal Reality of Tesla Depreciation
  2. The WeBuyAnyCar Experience: Convenience at a Cost
  3. Fighting Back: How to Get a Better Price for Your Tesla
  4. So, What's the Verdict? Is a Tesla a Bad Buy?
  5. Your Questions Answered (Sort Of)

The Brutal Reality of Tesla Depreciation

First off, it's not *just* WeBuyAnyCar being stingy, though they certainly don't help. The core of the problem is just brutal Tesla depreciation. That YouTuber, Harley Perkins, took his £52k Model Y in and got offered a measly £27,132 after a year [Source: UNILAD Tech]. That’s nearly half its value gone. Bonkers.

It's a bitter pill to swallow when you've been told you're buying the future. I used to think EVs would hold their value like granite, but I've completely changed my mind on that. The tech moves so fast that last year's model feels ancient when a new battery or software feature drops.

A Tesla Model Y being inspected at a WeBuyAnyCar branch, highlighting the Tesla resale value issue.

Fig-1: This is the scene of the crime for many owners—the WeBuyAnyCar valuation bay, where dreams of high resale value often die.

Why Are They Losing Money So Quickly?

It’s a perfect storm, really. The biggest culprit is Tesla itself. They slash prices on new cars whenever they feel like it, which instantly torpedoes the value of every single used one on the market. Why would anyone pay top dollar for your second-hand motor when they can get a brand new one for just a bit more? You can read more about the impact of Tesla price changes on resale value, but the short version is: it's a killer.

Then there's the sheer number of them now. A few years ago, a used Tesla was a rare find. Now, they're everywhere. More supply, same demand... prices drop. It’s basic economics, but it still stings.

The WeBuyAnyCar Experience: Convenience at a Cost

So you get an online valuation, which seems tempting. Then you get to the branch. This is where the magic—or the dark arts, depending on your view—begins. An inspector comes out with a tablet and starts hunting for imperfections you never knew existed. A tiny stone chip on the bonnet? That's a deduction. A scuff on the alloy from that one time you misjudged a kerb? Massive deduction.

They call it a "condition grade," and it’s how that juicy online quote gets whittled down to the real, much sadder number. Honestly, their business model is built on this. It's the price you pay for not having to deal with tyre-kickers on AutoTrader.

How Their Valuation Actually Works

The process is simple enough. You put your reg in online, they give you a price, you book a slot. But the WeBuyAnyCar car valuation process for Tesla, or any car for that matter, is designed for their profit, not yours. They're buying at trade price, minus a bit more for any perceived flaw, so they can shift it at auction and make a tidy profit. It’s a volume game.

You have to compare it to other places. A quick look on AutoTrader UK or Edmunds in the US will give you a much better idea of the *private* sale price. It’ll almost always be thousands more, but then you have the hassle of selling it yourself. It's the classic trade-off: cash now vs. more cash later.

A WeBuyAnyCar employee inspecting a Tesla, demonstrating the valuation process.

Fig-2: The inspection process. Every tiny imperfection is noted and will likely affect the final offer on your Tesla.

Fighting Back: How to Get a Better Price for Your Tesla

Okay, so you're determined to sell. What can you do? You’re not completely powerless. A little bit of prep goes a long, long way.

First, for heaven's sake, clean the car. Properly. Inside and out. A £50 valet can add hundreds to the offer because it just *looks* better cared for. I once tried to part-exchange a car after a long road trip without cleaning it and the dealer’s face said it all. Never again.

Oh, and I should have mentioned this earlier – get your paperwork in order. The full service history, any receipts for work done, the V5C logbook. Having a complete folder makes you look like a serious owner and gives them fewer reasons to chip away at the price. I completely messed this up when selling my old Golf GTI and it was a total nightmare of frantic searching and delaying the sale. Don't be like me.

Here’s a quick list of things to tick off:

  • Get it Cleaned: Don't just run it through a car wash, get it properly detailed.
  • Fix the Small Stuff: Got a stone chip? A little touch-up stick costs a tenner and might save you a hundred. Same for minor scratches.
  • Paperwork is King: Have every single document ready and organised in a nice little folder.
  • Software Updates: Make sure the car’s software is the latest version. It shows the car is up to date.
  • Shop Around: Get quotes from Motorway, Cazoo, and a dealer trade-in before you even think about accepting that first offer.

So, What's the Verdict? Is a Tesla a Bad Buy?

I realise I'm getting way too into the weeds here, but it's important. A Tesla isn't necessarily a bad purchase. They're amazing bits of tech. But you cannot buy one thinking it’s a financial investment. It's a car. And cars, especially ones from a company that changes its prices more often than I change my socks, lose money.

Interestingly, some data suggests they still hold their value better than other high-end EVs. That Porsche Taycan, for example, can lose value at an absolutely eye-watering rate [Source: Supercar Blondie]. So, it's all relative, I suppose. The entire used EV market is a bit of a Wild West right now.

Your Questions Answered (Sort Of)

People always ask, "How much is my Tesla worth to sell?" The honest answer is: whatever someone is willing to pay for it today. The first-year drop is the big one, maybe 40-50%. After that, it should level out a bit more [Source: Car Dealer Magazine UK]. Use KBB or Edmunds for a ballpark, but expect WeBuyAnyCar to come in under that.

And when they give you that low offer, can you justify a higher value? You can try. Waving your pristine service history in their face might help. Pointing out that it’s got the desirable wheels or interior colour might add a few quid. But at the end of the day, their offer is their offer. They know most people who come to them are there for the convenience, and that convenience has a hefty price tag.

So, is Tesla holding its value? Compared to the hype? No. Compared to some rivals? Yes, surprisingly. The market is just... volatile. My final piece of advice? Go in with your eyes wide open, your expectations low, and a portfolio of quotes from other buyers. Or, just be prepared for a bit of a shock.

Get Your (Probably Disappointing) Tesla WeBuyAnyCar Valuation Today

Sources

Read more